High performers tend to serve people the way they would want to be served. The best leaders ask first.
Most high performers believe the best way to serve people is to give them more. More detail. More follow-up. More effort. More of us.
Here’s the problem: more is how we would want to be served, not always how the other person wants it. The fix isn’t to care less. It’s to ask one question before we start: how much do you actually want?
The day someone fell asleep
I’ve been called intense more times than I can count. I’ve always taken it as a compliment, because it comes from a deep desire to give people the best experience possible.
Then a long-time partner of mine told me that someone she had sent my way felt exactly that. Too many texts. Too many videos. Too much, too fast. And around the same time, a client fell asleep in the middle of one of my strategy meetings. Fell asleep. I kept talking, because what else are you going to do?
But the more I thought about it, the more I had to admit the truth. It was boring for him. It was boring for me, too. Same information, same order, every single time, no matter who was on the other side of the table.
Why high performers over-serve
When you care about doing great work, it is easy to confuse “thorough” with “thoughtful.” We build one excellent process and run everyone through it, because it is the experience we would want.
The trouble is that people are not one personality type. Some people want every number, every option and every “what if.” Others want the bottom line and a clear next step, and anything beyond that feels like noise. When we give everyone the full treatment, we serve the first group well and quietly lose the second.
And we usually never hear about it. People rarely tell you that you were too much. They just go quiet.
Ask before you give
So I changed one thing. Now every one of those meetings starts with a question and a little honesty. I tell people that I used to walk everyone through the same route, every number they could ever want to know and probably a few they didn’t. Then I ask: where are you on that spectrum? Do you want all of it, or do you want the two or three things that matter most to you?
From there, we build the conversation around their answer instead of my script.
What changed when I started asking
- The meetings fit the person. Some now take ten minutes. People who already trust us look at the numbers and say, “We’re good, let’s go.” Others take an hour, and that is exactly right for them.
- I am not bored anymore. Every conversation is different, because every person is.
- Less wasted time, for everyone. The time we used to spend over-explaining now goes to the people who want the depth.
- People feel heard. The question itself tells them the meeting is about them, not about my process.
It’s true for the people we lead, too
This goes well beyond client meetings. Some people on your team want the full context behind every decision. Others want to know what you need and by when. Some want feedback in writing so they can think about it. Others want a quick conversation and to move on.
If you lead everyone the way you like to be led, you will be great for the people who are wired like you, and a little exhausting for everyone else. I’m still learning this one. I want to be great for every personality type, not just the ones who think like me and can run a thousand miles an hour.
Leading with the right amount
Being intense is not the problem. Caring a lot is never the problem. The problem is assuming that the amount that would help us is the amount that helps them.
The best experience isn’t the most information. It’s the right amount for the person in front of you.
So, who on your team, or at your table, would you serve better by asking first?
Bring this to your team
If your team is great at effort but sometimes overwhelms the people it serves, that is a leadership and systems conversation worth having. If you’d like to learn more about how I work with leaders and teams, take a deeper dive here. And if you’d like to bring this conversation to your team, you can reach me here.